Organizational Matters

At a gathering of education and non-profit leaders, I was asked to facilitate a conversation, to provide a “spark.” The organizers gave me a prompt, a statement as the basis of a short presentation. The prompt queried the effectiveness of networks of institutions to advance change. Do they? The organizers wanted to get the participants to start talking about higher educational organizations and their impact. It is a a more than reasonable request. In fact, considering the time and effort so many of us give to conferences, summits, and networks, it is a valuable question worthy of sustained consideration.

It strikes me that for many of my of colleagues, even though we all may claimed to feel siloed and working independently, higher education provides a rich soil organizations. Looking at things from a broader perspective, we are rife with ways of coming together.

The multitude of disciplinary and functional groupings immediately come to mind. Pick an academic discipline or an academic function, financial aid to IT to businesses offices to advisors, and there is a professional group. Or groups, as many disciplines and functions can support multiple groupings. In similar fashion, there are innumerable groupings based on geographic region, on identity (religion, race, ethnicity, gender). We also have groups and organizations keen to effect a particular change, be it advancing stronger first year of study or improved completion rates. All told, there have to be significantly more higher education related organizations than there are institutions of higher education.

While we may be bowling alone, we invariably head to conferences, organized by something or someone, to talk about it.

All that leads to an interesting question: which higher education organizations have facilitated what significant positive changes? Many have contributed and done things, to be sure, but gauging the impact of any one organization in a particular realm is a difficult, if not impossible, challenge. How have they done it? Is there a recipe, a secret sauce, that makes for an effective academic organization? It is a question beyond the scope of this post.

And why do we join, travel, log in and participate in so many of these groupings? Resume and c.v. bolstering, to be sure, is a factor, as are opportunities to learn and grow. We often wear multiple hats and have multiple professional identities in higher education. Organizations offer the nourishment to keep those identities vibrant. Ending my membership and subscriptions to history journals, as a personal example, was a fraught decision that involved much more than saving money and rationalizing that I could access the journals through my library. It meant, too, that in some way I was no longer thinking of myself as an historian. I have heard versions of that account from many friends and colleagues.

It is more, though, than personal and professional impetus that keep us trying to work together through organizations and groupings. Networks and organizations are necessary, yet perhaps not sufficient players in the development of effective higher education practitioners, units and institutions. They provide invaluable opportunities for us to find like-minded souls, to learn and share. This is essential in higher education. Each of us, each of our units, each of our institutions, has to determine its own best way to meet mission in particular and changing circumstances. What each of us have learned over the years, especially if we have worked in different institutions, is that there is no one best way. Instead, there are many better ways – and even more less effective ways. The only way to comprehend this and to gather the tools and skills is through conversation, study, and more conversation.

The value of networks and organizations in higher education is that they give us opportunities to talk with each other. Real power, especially to effect positive change, is in those conversations, communication and discussions, friendships and debates.

My “spark” at the event was along these lines with an important emphasis on human interaction. I believe that it is the people that makes organizations truly valuable: meaningful dialogue with each other. Journals and long c.v.s are fine, but they are not where the action is. I kept my presentation short, too, making sure that there was time for people to talk to each other.

Don’t just attend the presentation at your next organizational event. Make a friend and a connection. We need each other more than ever.

David Potash

No Quick Fixes: Black and White School

Dr. Cynthia Waszak Geary and Dr. LaHoma Smith Romocki, alumnae of Hillside High School, Durham, North Carolina, have done something very unusual: collaborated on a book about their experiences decades ago as Black and White high school students during a period of court ordered desegregation. In different classes and coming from different neighborhoods, Cindy and…

Poverty: Mission Matters

Education is the central mission of higher education. It’s what we do – our core function. It is far, though, from all that we do or have to do. For those of us who work in public education, in particularly in community colleges, the pursuit of mission depends in great part on the well-being of…

Oh So Many Costs

The value of a college education. The value proposition. The importance of getting that degree. The college experience. All of us who work in higher education, at one level or another, buy into the value of what a good college education can to do improve a student’s life. We see the benefits regularly, from the…

Migrant Workers Rights

Dedicated to “all low-wage undocumented workers,” Scaling Migrant Worker Rights: How Advocates Collaborate and Contest State Power is special kind of academic book. It spans disciplines and is equally strong in theory and data informed by direct research. Clearly written, the book shines a light on an extremely complex economic, political, and social issue: Mexican…

Left In, Left Out

Is higher education a cause, a consequence, a public or private good, a problem or a solution? Depends, I suppose, on the axe one is keen to sharpen. Increasingly I am finding discussions about higher education to sound like arguments about health care. It’s great if you’re wealthy, OK if you have some money and…

Leadership Lessons From the Navy

Imagine leadership in the military in your mind’s eye. I would wager that most of us would come up with the many of the same images of stoic heroism, courage under fire, sacrifice, valor and loyalty. Can’t you picture the soldier staring off into the distance, probably alone, with a look of resolve? Gritted teeth…