Vision and Elite Institutions

Many of the forces that make for quality in higher education are isomorphic:  impactful faculty scholarship and research, bigger libraries, better prepared students, more opportunities for academic and student support. Many of them simply boil down to more institutional money. It is a challenge to be different and to be better. That question is at the very heart of Mark William Roche’s new book, Realizing the Distinctive University: Vision and Values, Strategy and Culture.

Roche is a professor of German and philosophy at Notre Dame University, where he served as dean of the College of Arts and Letters for eleven years. Roche also held leadership roles at the Ohio State University. Despite his administrative responsibilities, Roche thinks like a faculty member. His head and heart are in scholarship and teaching. His perspective is valuable, for institutional excellence always demands excellence in the faculty.

Much of the book is about deaning – being an effective dean, explained through a mixture of higher education literature and personal experience. Roche owns up to his gaffes and is rightly proud of his successes. He is conscious about the shifts he made in style, communication and behavior, from faculty member to administrator. Literally, Roche writes that he made himself an extrovert. He notes that the stronger the institution’s faculty, the less intrusive the administration. Nevertheless, he is quite clear that leadership is essential to developing an academic vision and helping an institution of higher learning change and grow. It is about priorities and choices.

After setting out the broad landscape and challenges, Roche outlines the processes necessary to develop a strategic plan and vision. He argues that a vision can serve as the motivation to drive the many participants in a university – and especially the faculty – towards intellectual excellence. Working at the University of Notre Dame resonated with him, not only for its pursuit of academic and intellectual values, but also its Catholicism. Faith was a key factor in his leadership and in the development of the institution.

Realizing the Distinctive University contains much wisdom, and most of it is for those that work in well-funded, ambitious and élite universities – or those that care about them and want to advance their status. Roche writes about the broader higher education field, but his first-hand experience – and his interest – is in the research institution and leading faculty. Other issues just do not seem to stick with him.

Roche is not a disruptive thinker. Neither radical nor troubled about current debates, he does not expect any massive changes in higher education in the near future (at least at his institutions). Technology and the economy will force changes, to be sure, but they have done so in the past. Roche’s discipline is Germany and he contrasts the US system with the development of German’s higher education, but he does not situate his thinking – or his arguments – on the global stage. He acknowledges the international dimensions of thinking in a discipline, but he does not think through the special opportunities and obligations of a world-class research university. Roche is an incrementalist, a good administrator keen on building greatness.

Roche’s book is not self-congratulatory or smug; it is focused on a particular kind of research university and a particular kind of problem and opportunity. What it does, it does well. Stated plainly, Realizing the Distinctive University is best suited for those who are already several floors up in the ivory tower.

David Potash

Scandalous Schools

I don’t read Vanity Fair all that often. A few years back, when my dentist was fancy, copies of the magazine were in her waiting room. I read it. She consistently tried to up sell dental improvements, though, and once I tired of saying “no thanks” to the filling upgrades and invisible braces, I changed…

Locating the Finish Line: Completion Several Years On

Eight years ago, William Bowen, Matthew Chingos, and Michael McPherson wrote Crossing the Finish Line: Completing College at America’s Public Universities. A massive longitudinal study of student completions at a host of four-year public flagship institutions and state systems, the book was immediately recognized as an important work, a milestone in the effort to improve…

Political Science Prescience

Many years ago, as an undergraduate at Rice University, I took a course on political ideology. I wasn’t a political science major and I didn’t know anything about the professor, Fred Von der Mehden, before signing up. The class fit my schedule and completed a distribution requirement. My expectations were not high. I remember getting…

Undoing and Doing Together

It is rare to find a nonfiction page-turner about faculty and higher education. Faculty may be doing exciting and interesting things on a daily basis, but we do not often find about them on best-seller lists. Until Michael Lewis. Lewis is an extraordinarily successful writer. Beyond his journalism, magazine work and lesser-known efforts, he has…

Unacceptable is Unacceptable

Years ago I read a short piece about Richard Feynman, the Nobel-award winning physicist. I was intrigued. A genius who had the chops to work at the leading edge of his field and the communication skills to make science understandable to the public, he was known as brilliant, eccentric, dynamic, and the kind of thinker…

Doing Good and Giving Back

Higher education needs more friends like Robert Owen Carr. Fifty plus years ago Carr attended Lockport Township High School in rural Illinois. Thanks to a nomination from a high school counselor, Carr won $250 from a local woman’s club. The award made a big difference. Carr’s family of nine – six children, grandmother and two…